The liquid vs solid carbs debate in ultra running isn’t just about personal preference—it’s about optimizing gastric emptying, absorption rates, and preventing the catastrophic GI distress that ends more ultra races than injuries. Recent research reveals the answer is more nuanced than “one or the other,” and getting this wrong could cost you hours on race day.
The Science Behind Carbohydrate Form and Absorption
Your gut processes liquid and solid carbohydrates through fundamentally different mechanisms, with dramatic implications for ultra-distance performance.
Liquid Carbohydrates: Speed vs Sustainability
Liquid carbs from sports drinks, gels mixed with water, and liquid nutrition products enter your bloodstream significantly faster than solid foods. Studies show gastric emptying rates of 1.0-1.2 liters per hour for liquid carbohydrates versus only 200-300 grams per hour for solid foods.
Advantages: – Faster absorption during high-intensity efforts – Simultaneous hydration and fueling – Lower GI distress during hard running – Easier to consume on technical terrain
Disadvantages: – Less satisfying psychologically during long efforts – Requires carrying more liquid volume – Can cause blood sugar spikes and crashes – Doesn’t address “flavor fatigue” common after 12+ hours
Solid Carbohydrates: The Endurance Advantage
Real food and solid nutrition products require more digestive processing but offer unique benefits for ultra-distance events. Research from the Journal of Applied Physiology demonstrates that combining liquid and solid carbs improves fuel oxidation rates and reduces GI distress during efforts exceeding 6 hours.
Advantages: – More satisfying and addresses psychological need to “eat” – Provides variety to combat flavor fatigue – Slower, more sustained energy release – Often contains additional nutrients (sodium, potassium, protein)
Disadvantages: – Slower gastric emptying during high-intensity running – Requires more active digestion (blood flow to gut) – Can cause GI distress if consumed too rapidly – Harder to consume during steep climbs or technical descents
The Winning Strategy: Strategic Combination
Elite ultra runners don’t choose liquid vs solid carbs—they strategically combine both based on race phase, intensity, and individual tolerance.
Hours 1-4: Liquid Dominance
Start with 70-80% liquid carbohydrates when your pace is highest and stomach is most sensitive. Target 60-80g carbs per hour primarily from sports drinks and diluted gels.
Hours 5-12: Balanced Approach
Shift to 50/50 liquid and solid carbs as pace naturally decreases. This is when real food becomes not just tolerable but desirable. Consume 30-40g from liquids, 30-40g from solid foods (rice balls, potatoes, bars) per hour.
Hours 12+: Solid Priority
After half a day of running, most ultra runners experience severe flavor fatigue with sweet liquid carbs. Transition to 70-80% solid carbs from savory and real food options, supplemented with electrolyte drinks for hydration.
Race Intensity Matters
High-intensity sections (climbs, competitive pushes): Favor liquid carbs Low-intensity sections (aid station walks, flat cruising): Perfect for solid carbs
Key Takeaways
- Liquid carbs absorb 3-4x faster than solid carbs but cause more flavor fatigue in ultra events
- Optimal strategy combines both: 70% liquid early race, 50/50 mid-race, 70% solid late race
- Match carb form to intensity: liquid during hard efforts, solid during easier sections
- Individual gut training determines personal liquid vs solid carb tolerance ratios
- Plan to consume 60-90g total carbs per hour regardless of liquid/solid combination
Fuel Smarter, Not Harder
The liquid vs solid carbs debate in ultra running has a clear answer: both. Your fueling strategy should evolve throughout your race, shifting from primarily liquid carbs early when speed matters, to balanced mid-race, to solid-dominant late when psychological satisfaction and flavor variety become critical.
The key is testing your personal 70/30, 50/50, and 30/70 ratios during training runs of 4+ hours. Your gut’s tolerance to different carb forms under fatigue is highly individual—race day is not the time to discover your limits.
Outbound Links Included:
